top of page

Methodology for appraising aging Solar PV and Battery ESS energy systems

Writer: Soltell AdminSoltell Admin

The valuation of veteran solar photovoltaic (PV) and battery energy storage systems (ESS) has become increasingly important as these assets age and evolve under different operational and market conditions. Whether the energy systems operate under Feed-in-Tariff (FiT), power purchase agreement (PPA) schemes or rely on dynamic grid pricing such as System Marginal Price (SMP), a structured methodology ensures fair and accurate appraisal. This article outlines a comprehensive approach to assess the performance, degradation, and value of PV and ESS systems, ensuring that their true potential and health are accounted for in the valuation process.

Energy Management System pyramid conceptual scheme.
Fig 1. Valuation of aging solar PV and energy storage ESS sites is a challenge, with no comprehensive methodology.

Core Components of the Solar PV Appraisal Methodology

A thorough performance assessment forms the foundation of any system valuation. For PV and ESS systems, this involves evaluating real-time energy output or storage efficiency while accounting for environmental and operational factors. Historical performance data is also analyzed to establish trends and identify deviations caused by degradation or external disturbances. Advanced tools such as Soltell’s Sensorless technology play a pivotal role in this process by accurately assessing current and historical performance of PV and ESS. This enables a clear distinction between reversible losses, such as soiling or shading, and irreversible losses, such as cell degradation—a critical factor in fair valuation.


Degradation assessment is another key aspect, focusing on identifying the energy system’s maximum performance potential for its age and condition. This potential reflects the highest possible energy generation or storage capacity, considering standard degradation rates. By determining the gap between current performance and this maximum potential, the operational health of the system can be precisely quantified. This process ensures that both reversible and irreversible losses are accurately accounted for.


External disturbances, including soiling, shading, and suboptimal component configurations, often mask PV system’s true performance potential. Addressing these factors involves estimating the cost and effort required to mitigate reversible losses, such as cleaning soiled panels or removing shading obstructions. By incorporating these adjustments, the appraisal provides a fair representation of the system’s corrected performance.


For systems operating under FiT or PPA schemes, fixed revenue streams simplify valuation. However, systems reliant on dynamic pricing like SMP require a more nuanced approach. This involves modeling revenue potential by analyzing historical and projected grid prices, which helps estimate future income. Scenario planning is also essential to evaluate performance under varying grid price conditions, accounting for market volatility.


An accurate valuation must also consider the cost of restoring a system to its maximum potential. This includes replacing degraded components such as inverters or battery cells, addressing reversible losses like soiling or shading, and performing preventive maintenance to extend the system’s operational life. Once the current conditions are appraised, projections can be made for the future value of the system. This extrapolation process estimates future degradation rates based on historical data, adjusts for anticipated market conditions, and provides a fair valuation for both present and future scenarios.


Advantages of the Methodology

By prioritizing maximum potential and system health, this methodology delivers a transparent and precise approach to valuing solar photovoltaic (PV) and battery energy storage systems (ESS). It gives stakeholders—whether asset managers, investors, or operators—a clear picture of what these systems can truly achieve and how well they’re holding up under real-world conditions. This ensures valuations aren’t just theoretical but grounded in practical performance data, reflecting factors like wear and tear or operational efficiency. A key feature is its focus on distinguishing between reversible degradation (like surface soiling that can be cleaned) and irreversible damage (such as material fatigue), which prevents over- or under-pricing and promotes fairness in transactions.


Beyond accuracy, this approach adapts to today’s complex energy markets, making it especially valuable. It accounts for dynamic pricing models like the System Marginal Price (SMP), alongside traditional schemes like Feed-in-Tariffs (FiT) and Power Purchase Agreements (PPAs), ensuring relevance in a landscape where energy costs fluctuate. By analyzing how these systems perform under varying market conditions, it offers predictive insights into future output and worth. This forward-looking perspective empowers buyers and sellers to make smarter decisions, whether they’re negotiating a sale, planning upgrades, or assessing long-term investment viability.


Enhancing the Appraisal Process with Sensorless technology

Soltell’s Sensorless technology enhances the appraisal process by providing precise performance data without the need for extensive hardware on the site. It facilitates historical analysis to distinguish between reversible and irreversible degradation, supporting the determination of true renewable system potential. This ensures a fair and accurate valuation that reflects both current and historical performance trends.

Appraising veteran solar PV and ESS systems requires a nuanced approach that integrates performance assessment, degradation analysis, and external factor correction. By considering both current conditions and future projections, this methodology ensures a fair and transparent valuation, empowering stakeholders to make informed decisions. Soltell’s Sensorless technology adds unparalleled precision to the process, setting a new standard in system appraisal and valuation.


Ready to explore the advantages of Sensorless technology for energy system appraisal? Contact Soltell to learn more about how our solutions can transform energy management.



Comments


bottom of page